How Do Insurance Companies Evaluate Claims Related to Permanent Disabilities from Malpractice?

Suffering a permanent disability as a result of medical malpractice is a life-altering event. Permanent disabilities can dramatically reduce quality of life, create ongoing medical needs, and lead to significant financial burdens. For patients, pursuing compensation through a malpractice claim is essential for managing future care and recovering lost income. However, insurance companies, which are often responsible for covering malpractice payouts, evaluate these claims carefully in an effort to minimize the compensation paid.

Understanding how insurance companies assess malpractice claims related to permanent disabilities is essential for anyone navigating this process. This blog will explore the factors insurers consider when evaluating these claims and the common challenges patients face when seeking fair compensation. At LawMD, we have board-certified physicians who are also licensed attorneys and who specialize in medical malpractice cases.

Permanent Disabilities in the Context of Malpractice

Permanent disabilities are long-term or lifelong conditions that result in the loss of function, mobility, or independence. In the context of medical malpractice, these disabilities often stem from surgical errors, misdiagnoses, or improper treatment. Some common examples of permanent disabilities caused by malpractice include:

Paralysis: Resulting from nerve damage during surgery, failure to treat a spinal cord injury, or misdiagnosis of a critical condition like a stroke.
Amputations: Sometimes necessitated by untreated infections, delayed diabetes treatment, or surgical mistakes.
Severe Organ Damage: Damage to vital organs like the heart, kidneys, or liver due to misdiagnosis or improper treatment can lead to permanent disability.

These conditions often require ongoing or lifetime medical care, rehabilitation, and often require modifications to the patient’s home or lifestyle. They can also result in the inability to work, leading to a loss of future income and independence. When a permanent disability results from medical negligence, the affected individual can pursue a malpractice claim, often engaging the responsible healthcare provider’s insurance coverage.

How Insurance Companies Assess Malpractice Claims

Insurance companies handle malpractice claims by evaluating several key factors to determine the extent of the damages and the appropriate compensation. Because permanent disabilities carry long-term consequences, these claims are often more complex and involve more significant financial sums. Insurers take a detailed approach when determining liability and calculating the payout.

Severity of the Disability

The most important factor in evaluating a malpractice claim involving permanent disability is the severity of the condition. Insurers consider how the disability impacts the patient’s ability to function in daily life, including the need for assistive devices, modifications to living spaces, or long-term care facilities. For example, paralysis may require lifelong use of a wheelchair, physical therapy, and constant medical supervision. The more severe the disability, the higher the potential compensation for ongoing care.

Cost of Future Care

Permanent disabilities often involve significant future medical costs, such as surgeries, medications, therapy, and personal care assistance. Insurance companies evaluate medical records and expert testimony to estimate these expenses over the patient’s lifetime. The insurer will calculate economic damages (medical bills, rehabilitation, home modifications) and non-economic damages (pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life).

Patient’s Age and Earning Potential

Insurers also consider the patient’s age and how the disability affects their earning potential. Younger patients who are permanently disabled have longer life expectancies and may face decades of lost income if they can no longer work. This loss of earning capacity is factored into the compensation. For example, a 30-year-old who is paralyzed and unable to return to work will be entitled to compensation for lost wages for the remainder of their working years.

Medical Records and Expert Testimony

The patient’s medical records are essential for proving the disability resulting from medical malpractice. Insurance companies rely heavily on documentation of the original treatment, any errors made by healthcare providers, and the prognosis for the patient’s condition. In many cases, expert testimony is needed to demonstrate how the healthcare provider’s actions deviated from the accepted standard of care and how this negligence caused the disability. Expert opinions are also used to estimate future medical needs and associated costs.

Calculating Compensation for Pain and Suffering

Pain and suffering are components of malpractice claims, a critical factor in claims regarding permanent impairments. Insurance companies calculate compensation for pain and suffering by considering the patient’s physical pain, emotional distress, and loss of quality of life. For instance, a person who suffers a traumatic amputation may experience both physical pain and the psychological impact of losing a limb. Insurers often multiply the total economic damages by a number (usually between 1.5 and 5) to calculate non-economic damages.

Challenges in Obtaining Full Compensation

While insurance companies are responsible for covering malpractice claims, they are also businesses focused on minimizing payouts. As a result, claimants often face significant challenges when pursuing full compensation for permanent disabilities. Here are some common tactics insurance companies use:

Denying Liability: Insurance companies may dispute the healthcare provider’s responsibility for the disability. They may argue that the condition was pre-existing or that the healthcare provider followed the standard of care, meaning the injury was unavoidable. In these cases, expert testimony is critical for proving that the healthcare provider’s negligence caused the disability.
Offering Low Settlements: Insurance companies often start with low settlement offers even when liability is clear. They may underestimate the patient’s future medical costs or the impact of loss of earning capacity, resulting in a lower payout. Many claimants, overwhelmed by their situation, may feel pressured to accept these low offers, especially when facing mounting medical bills.
Disputing the Severity of the Disability: Insurers may attempt to downplay the severity of the patient’s disability. For example, they might argue that the patient’s condition will improve with rehabilitation or that they can still work in some capacity. These tactics are used to reduce the overall compensation.

Given these challenges, it is vital for individuals pursuing a malpractice claim to seek legal representation. An experienced medical malpractice attorney can evaluate the full extent of the damages, gather evidence, and negotiate with the insurance company to ensure a fair settlement.

The Benefits of Professional Legal Advocacy

Insurance companies play a significant role in determining the outcome of medical malpractice claims related to permanent disabilities. They assess factors such as the severity of the disability, future care costs, and lost earning capacity when calculating compensation. However, claimants often face challenges in obtaining full compensation, as insurance companies may use tactics to minimize payouts.

If you or a loved one has suffered a permanent disability due to medical malpractice, it is essential to consult an experienced attorney. Legal representation can help you navigate the grueling process of filing a claim and ensure you receive the compensation necessary to manage your condition and secure your future. As attorneys who are also physicians, we at LawMD are uniquely qualified to guide you through your medical malpractice case, helping you to achieve the best outcome possible.

Previous Next

How Do Insurance Companies Evaluate Claims Related to Permanent Disabilities from Malpractice?